Canada’s debate over intergenerational fairness is increasingly focused on Old Age Security.
Proposals from Senator Andrew Cardozo and Generation Squeeze founder Paul Kershaw to reduce OAS payments for seniors with higher household incomes call for government to redirect the savings toward younger Canadians facing unemployment and economic insecurity.
The concern is legitimate.
Young Canadians face extraordinary challenges. Housing costs have exploded. Stable employment has become harder to find. Student debt remains significant. Many young adults are postponing family formation and wealth accumulation. Governments should absolutely do more to support younger generations.
But the proposed solution reveals a growing weakness in Canada’s public policy debate. It confuses income with wealth. And because of that confusion, it risks weakening one of Canada’s most successful income security programs while doing little to address the underlying sources of intergenerational inequality.
The first problem is arithmetic. Cardozo emphasizes the size of OAS spending. He says federal spending on elderly benefits is expected to increase by $28 billion by 2029..
That sounds enormous. But the choice of denominator matters.
Proponents of Generation Squeeze measure OAS against selected federal spending priorities, particularly youth employment initiatives. Yet intergenerational equity is not a contest within a single federal budget envelope. It is a question about how resources are distributed across Canadian society as a whole.
Why compare OAS only to youth employment programs? Why not compare it to all federal expenditures or total government spending across federal, provincial, and municipal governments?
Or the hundreds of billions represented by tax expenditures, housing subsidies embedded in the tax system, and preferential treatment of wealth? The framing matters because it makes OAS appear uniquely responsible for fiscal pressures that arise from much larger policy choices.
The second problem is that the discussion focuses on gross spending while largely ignoring what happens after OAS is paid.
Unlike many government benefits, OAS is taxable income. Many recipients return a portion of their OAS through the income tax system. Higher-income seniors face the OAS recovery tax, commonly known as the clawback. At sufficiently high incomes, OAS disappears entirely.
Proponents of Generation Squeeze talk about the OAS clawback but treat OAS expenditures as though they flow only in one direction. They do not.
A meaningful discussion should distinguish between gross expenditures and net costs after taxes and recoveries are taken into account.
The third problem is the proposed household-income test itself. At first glance, basing OAS clawbacks on household income appears progressive. In reality, it creates significant new inequities.
Two households with identical incomes can face radically different circumstances. One retired couple earning $110,000 may enjoy excellent health, a paid-off home, and substantial investment assets. Another may spend tens of thousands of dollars annually on medications, home care, mobility supports, transportation, hearing aids, or dementia-related care. Yet both would be treated similarly under the proposed threshold.
This is especially problematic because the tax system already fails to recognize many of these costs adequately when determining OAS eligibility. Medical expenses generate tax credits but do not reduce the income measure used for OAS clawbacks. Charitable donations are similarly disregarded while certain investment-related deductions reduce income. The result is a definition of ability to pay that often reflects tax structure more accurately than actual financial capacity.
The fourth problem is conceptual. Proponents of Generation Squeeze repeatedly invoke intergenerational equity but rarely discusses wealth. Yet wealth is increasingly the defining feature of intergenerational inequality.
The divide between generations is not primarily driven by OAS.
It is driven by:
- housing wealth,
- inherited assets,
- investment portfolios,
- tax-free gains on principal residences,
- intergenerational transfers,
- and accumulated capital.
A retired couple with modest income but a $2 million mortgage-free home may appear only moderately affluent under an income test. A younger renter earning a high salary may appear affluent while possessing little wealth at all.
Income tells only part of the story.
Proposed solutions therefore attack a symptom while largely ignoring the disease. If Canada truly wishes to address intergenerational inequity, it must eventually confront the taxation of wealth itself.
That conversation would include questions about inheritances, principal residence exemptions, large capital gains, and the concentration of assets across generations.
Those are difficult political conversations. Cutting OAS is easier. But easier is not the same as effective.
The fifth problem is the underlying assumption that helping younger Canadians requires taking resources from seniors. This “Robin Hood” framing may be politically attractive, but it is analytically weak.
Canada did not reduce senior poverty by taking resources from children. It reduced senior poverty by deciding that old-age poverty was unacceptable.
Likewise, Canada can improve opportunities for younger Canadians without first weakening retirement security. The country is wealthy enough to do both.
Indeed, one of the great ironies of this debate is that the same governments that struggle to find money for young people routinely forgo billions through tax preferences tied to wealth accumulation. The choice is not between grandparents and grandchildren. It is between confronting wealth concentration directly or continuing to fight symbolic battles over income programs.
The final irony is that OAS is being criticized precisely because it succeeded.
Canada once had widespread senior poverty. OAS, GIS, CPP, and Medicare dramatically reduced it. That achievement is now being used as evidence that the system is too generous. Success has become the justification for retrenchment.
The lesson should be the opposite. The question is not whether Canada protected seniors too well. The question is why it failed to build comparable economic security for younger generations.
Intergenerational inequality is real. But reducing OAS for middle-income seniors will not solve it. If the problem is wealth, then wealth must eventually become the focus of policy.
Until then, Canada will continue debating income while the real sources of inequality remain largely untouched.
