How long does advocacy take? The only haul is the ‘long haul’ and there is no such thing as ‘drive-by’ advocacy  

  SOURCE: YouTube.com (watch the video) STATION: n/a PROGRAM: n/a TIME: 3:00 p.m. REFERENCE: Speech Toronto Housing Network DATE: July 18, 2009 LENGTH: 00:09:35 TRANSCRIPT: Stapleton Speech Toronto Housing Network Forum Margaret Hancock: John Stapleton from the Metcalf Foundation and St. Christopher House. JOHN STAPLETON: What I'd like to do is have you think of yourself going into a time machine, and you're going to go back 77 years to 1932. And if you could go in that time machine and think of what Toronto looked like in 1932, about five blocks from here, right at this time of year - there was during the month of July of 1932 a Royal Commission on Direct Relief run by Ontario's top businessman. At that time, it was a fellow by the…
Read More

The Open Policy Aptitude Test

The following policy aptitude test is administered on occasion to policy classes I attend at various levels. Many classes have scored 0 out of 20 and then missed all the tiebreakers. I don’t get asked to address many classes.   Spell Westminster (question issued orally)   Common reply puts in an extra 'i'   What is the symbol on a government member's business card?   A coat of arms (if they can get that, I award a point) - 'some type of crown' gets no points   What is the symbol on a public servant's business card?   - Ontario - Trillium (or) - Canada - stylized flag of Canada in red   Do cities have a distinction between political folk and public servants in terms of the symbols on…
Read More

Doing social policy: The 10 elements

 Here is  a PDF of the ten elements of social policy advocacy that will connect with the public. It is a simple checklist based on John Kenneth Galbraith's 4 part concept of the conventional wisdom and Jonathan Haidt's 6 elements of the moral palette. Only Gandhi and Mandela have promoted movements that touch on all ten.
Read More

The rise and fall of welfare analysis in Canada

As a lifelong student of social assistance caseloads in Canada, I looked forward to The Rise and Fall of Social Assistance Use in Canada, 1969-2012 by Ron Kneebone and Katherine White. My interest became even more avid when I read that the authors had cited some my data to come to their conclusions. The report is reasonably fair in its approach even if it does not mention or analyse the most important reasons why welfare caseloads have risen and fallen in Canada. But that was before I read the news release supporting the report which comes to remarkably different conclusions than the report itself. Its chiding tone and speculative welfare baiting made me wonder if the real news release supporting the report was somehow mislaid or ‘separated at birth’. I…
Read More

When zero-tolerance prevails: very fast drivers, three Senators, and Toronto’s mayor

Zero tolerance and unwritten rules There is a sign facing traffic on the southbound Don Valley Parkway in Toronto between York Mills Road and Lawrence Avenue that announces that the 90km per hour speed limit will be enforced with zero tolerance. The sign has been there for as long as I can remember likely dating from the mid 1990’s, shortly after the phrase was coined. “The term "Zero Tolerance" appeared for the first time in a report in 1994. The idea behind this expression can be traced back to the Safe and Clean Neighborhoods Act, approved in New Jersey in 1973…..According to scholars, zero tolerance is the concept of giving carte blanche to the police for the inflexible repression of minor offenses… ”[1] During periods when the Don Valley Parkway was not   congested, I conducted the personal experiment…
Read More

Teaching what I want to teach because I like what I like…..another last word on David Gilmour

At bottom, David Gilmour conflates personal interest with public policy and tries to make the case that the arena in which he practices the former should be indistinguishable from the latter. The private and public in his case become one.  (More about that later!) OK - all of us have private interests that are ultimately legitimate for any of us to indulge if they don't hurt others: football, beer, ballet, origami, the Ballet Russe, poutine and/or crepe suzette. No matter. It's on your own time with your own friends... on your own nickel.  We are bored with your choices but thank God you did not invite us! Yet once I say in a public forum that I accept pay from a public institution with public funding to indulge my private…
Read More

Accidentally green & inadvertently poor? The strange case of the District of Scarborough Ontario

First it was a community, then a city, then a municipality and now a District in the Toronto megacity. Scarborough is a very interesting place to live in the new millennium because it is accidentally green and inadvertently poor. When I began analysing the data on the working poor in Toronto for the Metcalf Foundation, I began to notice that the community I have lived in for 35 years was becoming poorer. Here is an excerpt from the Working Poor in the Toronto Region “Although increases and decreases are largely in balance west of Scarborough, far more increases in working poverty (increases of more than 10%) occur east of Yonge Street. More decreases occur west of Yonge Street. In other words, the … working poor seem to be moving eastward.”…
Read More

How do we begin a dialogue about inequality with conservative Canadians?

As someone who spent a career in social welfare, I have often been a sounding board for conservative acquaintances, particularly those who are advanced in years. “I say, let them starve,” one of my relatives declared to me at a family dinner. What he meant by that is: “Why don’t these people behave? Why don’t they just do what they’re supposed to do? I went out, I worked hard, why shouldn’t they work hard? And if they don’t work hard, then they should starve.” In pondering how to respond to sentiments like these, I have been much aided by Jonathan Haidt, author of The Righteous Mind: Why Good People are Divided by Politics and Religion.[1]  Haidt himself is a liberal social democrat. But he has successfully analysed why conservatives and…
Read More

How do you replace social policy? With ‘decision-based evidence making’[i]

Social policy, at its simplest and most active, is the articulation of ideas to effect positive change for people based on strong principles and the best available evidence. Social policy is a good thing and is historically a strong suit of governments. Therefore, it is extremely interesting that Canada now has a federal government that appears to wish to get out of social policy. They are achieving this end in five ways: Through staff cuts and attrition in the  government departments like Human Resources and Skills Development Canada (HRSDC) that do social policy; By declaring that large aspects of social policy like poverty reduction are  the responsibility of someone else ( i.e. provinces) By making sure that charities do not conduct social policy that could be construed to have political…
Read More