A young person’s guide to a guaranteed annual or basic income – Part 3

Blog
What to do with our emotionally charged income security system To many, a GAI or basic income looks like a bauble or a confection. It’s up there with solving gridlock,  reducing global warming and curing cancer. Easy to want and easy to say – wicked hard to do! The problem with a GAI is not unlike the problem of unicorns - they are beautiful but don't exist. Bringing a GAI or BI into existence would be extremely difficult as a horrendous load of problems face designers within the first minute of study. Growing a horn on a horse might well be easier. More than anything, the GAI suffers the same problem as 'world peace' in that it is an absolutely pure idea that would, in one fell swoop, make us all…
Read More

A young person’s guide to a guaranteed annual or basic income –part 2

Blog
A Valentine’s Day gift for benefit designers – a tale of two GAI’s Last week, I self-published: A young person’s guide to a guaranteed annual or basic income[1]. In the Toronto Star on Saturday February 12, there was a lead editorial[2] on Guaranteed and basic incomes that set out the usual cautions about beautiful unicorns that don’t exist. I won’t go into the details here. Instead, I want to build on my essay of one week ago and talk about two real people – two seniors - that already have guaranteed annual incomes. One is comfortable and the other is poor. The first is my father and the second is a woman for whom I have advocated. Her name is Linda Chamberlain. Let’s start with my father. He is 96…
Read More

The Open Policy Aptitude Test

Blog
The following policy aptitude test is administered on occasion to policy classes I attend at various levels. Many classes have scored 0 out of 20 and then missed all the tiebreakers. I don’t get asked to address many classes.   Spell Westminster (question issued orally)   Common reply puts in an extra 'i'   What is the symbol on a government member's business card?   A coat of arms (if they can get that, I award a point) - 'some type of crown' gets no points   What is the symbol on a public servant's business card?   - Ontario - Trillium (or) - Canada - stylized flag of Canada in red   Do cities have a distinction between political folk and public servants in terms of the symbols on…
Read More

City of Toronto Budget Deputation: John Stapleton; Scarborough, January 13, 2016: 6:00 p.m.

Blog
I am a newly minted senior citizen. I have lived in Scarborough for the past 37 years. I am a proud resident of Scarborough but I see a problem. I see the problem of poverty in Toronto. I think that we can and should do more to eradicate poverty in our city Toronto is the largest and richest city in Canada Our economy comprises almost 11 per cent of Canada’s GDP,  And in recent years Toronto has been ranked: The world's most tax-competitive major city (KPMG Competitive Alternatives 2014: Focus on Tax) The 2014 Intelligent Community of the Year (Intelligent Community Forum) Fourth on Price Waterhouse Coopers’ Cities of Opportunity (PwC, 2014); and The world's most resilient city (Grosvenor Group, 2014)[1] But there is another side to Toronto. Toronto houses Canada’s highest…
Read More

Life and Fun in 2016

Blog
There are a lot of fun things to do in 2016: Here are my top four, highly idiosyncratic entries,  all from watching evening television on Netflix or CBC Praise Keith Richards – Rock Historian: Tune into Netflix and go to the music documentaries. It takes a while until you realize that Keith Richards is in almost all of them. He has raised the halting carefulness of the intoxicant trying to keep it together to high art. But don’t let the highly practiced ‘stoned’ style (and a 70+ year old wearing a headband) distract you or make you think that this isn’t serious. Keith Richards is THE historian of rock and roll. He traces it – he spins it. He plays it. He takes you from Muscle Shoals to clubs in Chicago.…
Read More

On self exemption, framing and location: a meditation on race and other elements of personal biography that cannot be changed

Blog
What can we not change? I want to use the word ‘racism’ in its broadest sense – much broader than it is currently used. The reason is that race is only one aspect of our humanity that no one can change. We can’t change our place of origin. All of us were born in one of about 200 nations on earth. We can however, change our nationality through immigration. We can renounce our place of origin. We can’t change our ethnicity. Ethnicity is a part of our personal biography that none of us can change. We can change our proclivities, however. Each of us can orient ourselves towards other ethnicities through dress, the food we eat, and social behaviour. We can’t change our race. Race is also an element of…
Read More

Social Assistance in Ontario: Periods of Tumult and Calm

Blog
For the first time in over a year and without much fanfare, the Ontario Government has begun to publish monthly social assistance caseload numbers. One guesses that the reason for the hiatus was the much-reported troubles with their new social assistance computer system called SAMS. The newest figures are for November 2015 and the new charts on the MCSS website include caseload figures going back two years including  the 13 months from November 2014 to November 2015 that were missing. They are here for Ontario Works: http://www.mcss.gov.on.ca/documents/en/mcss/social/reports/OW_EN_2015-11.pdf and here for ODSP: http://www.mcss.gov.on.ca/documents/en/mcss/social/reports/ODSP_EN_2015-11.pdf This has allowed me to update an excel file which many readers have seen in the past that includes reliable data for the last 35 years (since 1981) for caseloads (payments) , beneficiaries (men women and children receiving assistance), unemployment, and population. Some…
Read More

Time to look at income security for low income older adults with disabilities

Blog
One of the long term goals I have for Open Policy is to cover all aspects of income security for all age groups for low income people with and without disabilities. This year, Open Policy managed to add a critical piece with the publication of Every Ninth Child in Ontario: A Cost-Benefit Analysis for Investing in the Care of Special Needs Children and Youth in Ontario with my colleagues Alexa Briggs, Celia Lee, Brendon Pooran and Rene Doucet. Children and youth with disabilities and their income security needs are extremely important and I hope there will be more contributions from my colleagues and I on this front in the future. The following is a chart that I have had in my head for years but I never sat down and…
Read More

Hunter Gatherers in Toronto: “What a long strange trip it’s been”

Blog
 “As soon as the rent is paid, first thing I do is stock up on food, which generally means I've got three days’ worth of food. For the rest of the month I hit soup kitchens, food banks. And I'm allowed to hit the food bank four times a month.  The clothes exchanges provide the clothing, but the problem is, because I haven't been eating healthy for the last ten years, I'm pretty underweight. So finding clothes that fit, pants especially, I'm currently taking like a 26/30 which is almost impossible to find.” - 59 year old single male social assistance recipient in Toronto   A hunter-gatherer is defined as follows by dictionary.com: “A member of a group of people who subsist by hunting, fishing, or foraging in the wild.”[1]…
Read More

Scarborough Wants In!

Blog
Toronto Tourism growing in importance In the afterglow of the Pan/Parapan Am Games, Toronto residents have fixated on tourism revenue and city building as important dividends arising from our successful hosting job. And now that the Games’ success has bolstered support for other hosting opportunities, new infrastructure projects and unprecedented levels of tourism are now within sight. Torontonians recognize the benefits of drawing visitors to the various attractions, businesses and neighbourhoods that define our city and showcase its unique character.   Toronto is home to an enviable array of urban and natural enclaves, diverse cultural experiences, food, entertainment and world-class retail. Tourism Toronto guide is the official guide but shortchanges Scarborough That’s why visitors and locals turn to the Official Toronto Tourist Guide produced by Tourism Toronto, the official destination marketing…
Read More