A modern morality play
“We have strengthened the incentive and weakened the capacity.”
Margaret Atwood
Payback
In Christopher Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus, the devil (Lucifer) summons the Seven Deadly Sins to entertain the doctor. Pride, Covetousness, Wrath, Envy, Gluttony, Sloth and Lechery appear one by one, each explaining its particular contribution to human wickedness.
Faustus is delighted. Having sold his soul to the devil, he is understandably anxious to see what he has purchased.
It is one of the more memorable scenes in English theatre. The sins are not especially frightening. They are vain, foolish, self-important and quite pleased with themselves. Their great advantage is that they are allowed to speak.
Margaret Atwood, in Payback: Debt and the Shadow Side of Wealth, reminds us that our economic arrangements are not nearly as free of moral judgment as we like to believe. Debt is not simply a financial obligation. It has a long association with guilt, punishment, obligation and redemption.
Welfare has much the same inheritance.
We have never been entirely comfortable giving money to people who have none. We want to help them, certainly, but not so much that they might become accustomed to being helped. We want them to become independent, but we also want to be satisfied that they are sufficiently uncomfortable in the meantime.
This has produced a remarkable collection of rules.
The rules are designed to encourage people to work, acquire skills, take responsibility for themselves and become independent. Unfortunately, many of the activities through which people normally achieve these things are themselves subject to restrictions, financial penalties or administrative examination.
I have been wondering what Marlowe’s Seven Deadly Sins might look like if Lucifer were to summon them today.
Not in hell. In an Ontario welfare office. And what if they could speak as in Marlowe’s Faust?
The sins would have changed. They would now be Work, Training, Family Help, Sharing Accommodation, Saving Money, Collaboration and Travel.
All seven are considered virtues in the general population.
Their moral character becomes less certain when practised by people receiving welfare.
The First Sin: Work
Enter Work.
I am Work.
I understood that the government wanted me to find employment. Indeed, I had been given to understand that this was practically its principal interest in my existence.
So, I found some.
Not a great deal, admittedly. A few hours here and there. But I thought it might lead to something.
I discovered that Ontario Works allows me to earn $200 a month in net employment income before reducing my assistance. After that, it ordinarily takes away 50 cents for every additional dollar I earn.
I was told this was an incentive to work.
The $200 exemption was introduced in 2013, when Ontario’s minimum wage was $10.25 an hour. The minimum wage is now $17.95.
The exemption remains $200.
This is a rather economical way of encouraging employment. It requires no annual adjustment and very little imagination.
The government has been generous enough to allow the rewards of full-time work to increase substantially. It has simply been less enthusiastic about the rewards of beginning to work.
The Second Sin: Training
Enter Training.
I am Training.
I have heard a great deal about the importance of skills.
Governments appear particularly fond of skills. They announce training programs, celebrate apprenticeships, establish funds and appear in photographs with people wearing hard hats.
I thought I might acquire some skills myself.
I found a course that could improve my chances of employment. Unfortunately, I discovered that education and training have to fit within the requirements of the assistance program.
Not every course or schedule necessarily qualifies.
This was disappointing, as I had assumed that the purpose of training was to make me more employable.
I was reminded that I was expected to look for work.
I explained that I was trying to become qualified for work.
Apparently, there is a distinction.
It is one that people already in employment seldom have to contemplate when their employers send them on courses.
The Third Sin: Family Help
Enter Family Help.
I am Family Help.
My mother was concerned about me. She knew that I was having difficulty managing and offered some money.
I thought this was rather kind.
Then I discovered that gifts and voluntary payments are subject to welfare rules. Some are exempt, and Ontario has made allowances for family assistance. Nevertheless, I needed to establish how the rules applied and whether the money had to be reported.
My mother found this surprising.
She had been under the impression that helping one’s children was a family matter.
The government regularly reminds us of the importance of strong families, personal responsibility and mutual support.
It is reassuring to know that these principles remain important enough to require administrative oversight.
The Fourth Sin: Sharing Accommodation
Enter Sharing Accommodation.
I am Sharing Accommodation.
I thought that if two people shared a place, they could divide the rent, utilities and other expenses.
It seemed a modest contribution to solving the housing crisis.
But I discovered that living arrangements can affect social assistance. In particular, if two people are considered spouses, their assistance is calculated differently.
Not every roommate is a spouse. The rules make distinctions, and these distinctions must be understood.
This means that a person contemplating a change in living arrangements may need to consider not only whether it is affordable, convenient or agreeable, but also how the welfare administration will interpret it.
For everyone else, sharing accommodation is commonly described as sensible financial management.
For people receiving welfare, it can become a matter of considerable administrative interest.
The housing crisis is serious, of course. We must not allow people to solve it too casually.
The Fifth Sin: Saving Money
Enter Saving Money.
I am Saving Money.
I had been advised to put something aside for emergencies.
This advice was everywhere. Financial institutions, governments and public educators seemed united in their enthusiasm for saving.
So, I began.
I thought I might eventually buy a used car, move closer to employment or have enough money to survive an unexpected expense.
Then I learned about asset limits.
Ontario Works generally allows a single recipient to retain $10,000 in non-exempt assets. There are exceptions for certain assets, but the principle remains.
At some point, having accumulated enough resources to make life more secure can mean becoming ineligible for assistance.
This is an interesting approach to financial independence.
The government encourages people to establish emergency funds, save for retirement and build assets.
It simply prefers that welfare recipients not get too far ahead of themselves.
One must presumably become independent without accumulating too many of the things that make independence possible.
The Sixth Sin: Collaboration
Enter Collaboration.
I am Collaboration.
A few of us thought we might start a small enterprise.
One had some technical skills. Another knew how to keep accounts. Someone else had contacts who might become customers.
None of us had enough resources to do much alone. Together, we thought we might have a chance.
This is the sort of thing governments generally applaud.
Entrepreneurship is said to be the engine of the economy. Governments encourage innovation, partnerships, risk-taking and investment. They offer grants, loans, tax preferences and other inducements to people willing to try something new.
We discovered that self-employment was permitted on assistance, but that we would have to understand the rules governing business income, allowable expenses, assets and reporting.
There were calculations to make and consequences to consider.
The government is understandably anxious that people without money should not undertake ill-considered financial risks.
People with money, on the other hand, are frequently encouraged to take risks with the assistance of public money.
There is no contradiction here that cannot be explained by a sufficiently detailed regulation.
The Seventh Sin: Travel
Enter Travel.
I am Travel.
I heard there might be employment in another community. I had relatives who could accommodate me while I investigated.
I thought I might go and see.
Governments regularly encourage labour mobility. Workers are told to go where the jobs are, adapt to changing economic circumstances and be prepared to relocate.
But Ontario Works has rules governing absences from the province. Extended absences can affect eligibility unless an exception or approval applies.
Travel is not prohibited, of course. There are provisions for particular circumstances.
Nevertheless, someone contemplating a trip must consider how it fits within the rules.
I had thought that going somewhere else might help me find employment.
It appears that one must be careful not to become too mobile while attempting to achieve labour mobility.
A Word from the Administration
Marlowe’s sins are allowed to explain themselves, and Faustus is delighted by their performances.
Our seven modern sins might produce a rather different reaction.
Consider what they have in common.
Work provides income and experience. Training improves qualifications. Family help supplies resources. Sharing accommodation reduces costs. Saving provides security. Collaboration creates opportunities. Travel allows people to pursue them elsewhere.
These are not eccentric activities.
They are the ordinary things that people do to improve their circumstances.
Governments encourage all seven, often with considerable enthusiasm and public expenditure.
But for welfare recipients, each can involve a calculation, restriction, reporting obligation or possible reduction in assistance.
None is universally forbidden. The rules contain exemptions, permissions and exceptions. There are legitimate reasons to establish eligibility and prevent abuse.
The difficulty is that the accumulated effect can make it remarkably complicated to undertake activities that would otherwise be considered entirely sensible.
The welfare administration has become very accomplished at determining whether people are poor enough to qualify for assistance.
It has been somewhat less successful at designing rules that help them stop qualifying.
The Eighth Sin
There is, I think, an eighth sin that Marlowe overlooked.
It is the confusion of incentives with capabilities.
In 1995, before the Harris welfare cuts, a single person’s assistance represented approximately 56% of full-time minimum-wage earnings.
Today, Ontario Works provides $733 a month, less than 24% of full-time minimum-wage earnings.
The gap between welfare and wages has widened enormously.
This is generally regarded as a triumph of incentives.
And in one sense, it is.
A person receiving assistance has a much greater financial incentive to obtain full-time employment. Equally, someone already earning a minimum wage has a much greater financial incentive to remain employed rather than turn to welfare.
The incentive operates in both directions.
Indeed, the gap has become so large that Ontario could substantially improve welfare rates without coming close to making assistance as financially rewarding as full-time minimum-wage employment.
Yet the Ontario Works rate has remained at $733 since 2018.
The government has evidently concluded that an incentive cannot be too strong.
There is, however, a complication.
Higher wages make jobs more attractive, and not just to people receiving welfare.
They attract applicants who may already have employment, recent experience, reliable transportation, stable housing, credentials and other advantages.
If minimum wages become genuinely livable, these jobs may become more desirable still. Depending on the labour market, employers may have an even larger pool of applicants from which to choose.
This is excellent news for employers.
It is not necessarily excellent news for the welfare recipient who has spent years trying to survive on an increasingly inadequate income.
That person may have the greatest financial incentive to work of anyone applying.
Unfortunately, employers are not in the business of measuring financial desperation.
They generally prefer applicants who appear capable of doing the job.
And the very things that make a person employable—stable housing, adequate nutrition, transportation, suitable clothing, training, recent experience and some financial resilience—are difficult to maintain on $733 a month.
We have therefore achieved something rather unusual.
We have made employment progressively more rewarding while making some of the people who most need employment progressively less able to compete for it.
We have strengthened the incentive and weakened the capacity.
And when people fail to find employment, we are inclined to conclude that the incentive must still be insufficient.
This is an especially convenient conclusion because it allows the policy to be judged by the very failure it may be helping to produce.
The Moral of the Story
Atwood’s great insight in Payback is that economic obligations carry moral judgments long after we have convinced ourselves that we are dealing only with money.
Welfare is not simply an income-support program. It is also a system for making judgments about behaviour.
We distinguish between deserving and undeserving circumstances. We decide which forms of help are acceptable, which resources may be retained and which activities require explanation.
We have become very concerned that assistance might discourage independence.
Less attention has been paid to the possibility that the rules themselves might discourage the activities through which independence is achieved.
The seven modern sins are not really sins at all.
They are the things we recommend to everyone else.
Work more. Improve your skills. Ask your family for help. Share expenses. Save for emergencies. Start something with others. Move where the opportunities are.
These are the standard prescriptions for getting ahead.
For people on welfare, they come with a set of instructions.
In Marlowe’s play, Faustus makes a bargain that promises him knowledge and power. He eventually discovers that the bargain has delivered considerably less than he expected.
Our welfare system has made a bargain of its own.
We have accepted the proposition that making assistance less attractive will encourage people to become independent.
The proposition is not entirely wrong. Financial incentives matter.
But it is incomplete.
Making people more anxious to obtain employment does not necessarily make them more employable. Making welfare less attractive does not make jobs more attainable. And making poverty more difficult to endure does not necessarily make it easier to escape.
Perhaps the most curious feature of the system is that it can regard a person who remains poor and complies with the rules as administratively unremarkable, while someone who tries to change their circumstances may generate an impressive amount of paperwork.
Marlowe gave us seven deadly sins.
Ontario’s welfare administration has managed to find seven more.
And, like the originals, they appear to be remarkably difficult to give up.
Addendum
From Marlowe’s Dr. Faustus
Enter the SEVEN DEADLY SINS.
Now, Faustus, examine them of their several names and dispositions.
FAUSTUS. What art thou, the first?
PRIDE. I am Pride. I disdain to have any parents. I am like to
Ovid’s flea; I can creep into every corner of a wench; sometimes,
like a periwig, I sit upon her brow; or, like a fan of feathers,
I kiss her lips; indeed, I do—what do I not? But, fie, what a
scent is here! I’ll not speak another word, except the ground
were perfumed, and covered with cloth of arras.
FAUSTUS. What art thou, the second?
COVETOUSNESS. I am Covetousness, begotten of an old churl, in an
old leathern bag: and, might I have my wish, I would desire that
this house and all the people in it were turned to gold, that I
might lock you up in my good chest: O, my sweet gold!
FAUSTUS. What art thou, the third?
WRATH. I am Wrath. I had neither father nor mother: I leapt out
of a lion’s mouth when I was scarce half-an-hour old; and ever
since I have run up and down the world with this case
of rapiers, wounding myself when I had nobody to fight withal.
I was born in hell; and look to it, for some of you shall be
my father.
FAUSTUS. What art thou, the fourth?
ENVY. I am Envy, begotten of a chimney-sweeper and an oyster-wife.
I cannot read, and therefore wish all books were burnt. I am lean
with seeing others eat. O, that there would come a famine through
all the world, that all might die, and I live alone! then thou
shouldst see how fat I would be. But must thou sit, and I stand?
come down, with a vengeance!
FAUSTUS. Away, envious rascal! —What art thou, the fifth?
GLUTTONY. Who I, sir? I am Gluttony. My parents are all dead,
and the devil a penny they have left me, but a bare pension, and
that is thirty meals a-day and ten bevers, —a small trifle
to suffice nature. O, I come of a royal parentage! my grandfather
was a Gammon of Bacon, my grandmother a Hogshead of Claret-wine;
my godfathers were these, Peter Pickle-herring and Martin
Martlemas-beef; O, but my godmother, she was a jolly gentlewoman,
and well-beloved in every good town and city; her name was Mistress
Margery March-beer. Now, Faustus, thou hast heard all my progeny;
wilt thou bid me to supper?
FAUSTUS. No, I’ll see thee hanged: thou wilt eat up all my victuals.
GLUTTONY. Then the devil choke thee!
FAUSTUS. Choke thyself, glutton! —What art thou, the sixth?
SLOTH. I am Sloth. I was begotten on a sunny bank, where I have
lain ever since; and you have done me great injury to bring me
from thence: let me be carried thither again by Gluttony and
Lechery. I’ll not speak another word for a king’s ransom.
FAUSTUS. What are you, Mistress Minx, the seventh and last?
LECHERY. Who I, sir? I am one that loves an inch of raw mutton
better than an ell of fried stock-fish; and the first letter
of my name begins with L.
FAUSTUS. Away, to hell, to hell!
[Exeunt the SINS.]
LUCIFER. Now, Faustus, how dost thou like this?
FAUSTUS. O, this feeds my soul!
