Facts, frames, and the vanishing denominator: Evidence collapses when scale disappears
We have spent years worrying about misinformation: false claims, fabricated statistics, outright lies. That concern, while justified, now risks missing the deeper epistemic or ‘knowledge’ failure unfolding in public life. Increasingly, the problem is not that facts are wrong, but that facthood itself is being narrowed, stripped of context, and weaponized in ways that make reasoned disagreement impossible. This is where decision-based evidence making meets Daniel Kahnemann’s quieter but equally corrosive failure: denominator neglect. True but meaningless Another Daniel — Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s reminder that people are entitled to their own opinions but not their own facts — assumed something that no longer reliably holds: that facts arrive intact, with their scale, probability, and relevance understood. In practice, facts now circulate as fragments, detached from base rates, denominators, and comparative…
