Facts, frames, and the vanishing denominator: Evidence collapses when scale disappears

Blog
We have spent years worrying about misinformation: false claims, fabricated statistics, outright lies. That concern, while justified, now risks missing the deeper epistemic or ‘knowledge’ failure unfolding in public life. Increasingly, the problem is not that facts are wrong, but that facthood itself is being narrowed, stripped of context, and weaponized in ways that make reasoned disagreement impossible. This is where decision-based evidence making meets Daniel Kahnemann’s quieter but equally corrosive failure: denominator neglect. True but meaningless Another Daniel — Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s reminder that people are entitled to their own opinions but not their own facts — assumed something that no longer reliably holds: that facts arrive intact, with their scale, probability, and relevance understood. In practice, facts now circulate as fragments, detached from base rates, denominators, and comparative…
Read More

The NEET generation and the neural economy of disconnection

Blog
Every generation invents a new language for its discontent. For many of today’s young people, that language is withdrawal. Across Canada and other rich countries, a growing share of youth are classified as NEET — Not in Employment, Education, or Training. Policymakers read the acronym as an economic problem. But the truth is more profound: the NEET generation is signaling a collective breakdown in how modern societies cultivate motivation, attention, and belonging. They are not “lost” or “lazy.” Many are simply overloaded — neurologically, cognitively, and emotionally — by institutions designed for a different brain and a different world. The new neural landscape Over the past two decades, diagnoses of ADHD, autism spectrum disorder, anxiety, and depression have risen sharply among youth. Some of that increase reflects better awareness, but…
Read More

The compliment–devalue–rescue routine

Blog
Anyone who has dealt with a high pressure salesperson, a hard-nosed buyer, or an “experienced” auction intermediary will recognize the pattern. Compliment It begins with flattery. You are praised for your discernment. Your item is described as rare, interesting, even impressive. The seller establishes rapport by affirming your intelligence and taste. This is not incidental. The compliment lowers your guard and creates a subtle obligation to remain reasonable and cooperative. Devalue Then comes the turn. Despite its apparent value, you are told the item is “hard to place.” Demand is thin. The market is soft. There are flaws you may not have noticed—minor, perhaps, but important to “serious buyers.” You are reminded that rarity does not guarantee liquidity, and that other valuables like yours are quietly circulating. The message is…
Read More

From favelas to encampments: Why some settlements stay and others are cleared

Blog
During my recent trip through Fortaleza, Recife, Salvador, Rio de Janeiro, São Paulo, and Porto Alegre, I was struck by the permanence of the informal settlements I saw. In Rio, favelas — sprawling, self-built communities — have existed for generations. Some, like Morro da Providência, trace roots to the late 19th century. Today Brazil’s national statistics institute estimates that nearly 16 million people live in favelas and similar urban communities across the country — about 8 % of the national population of 240 million people. These are not transient summer encampments; they are enduring, multi-generational neighbourhoods with their own economies and social fabrics. By contrast, when unhoused people in Canada and the United States build encampments under bridges or in parks, the state almost always responds with eviction and clearance.…
Read More

Of Prine, Ferlinghetti and Ochs circa 1973: What I didn’t know I was collecting

Blog
In 1973, I was twenty-two, with a newly finished master’s degree - too early - yet convinced that ideas mattered—especially the ones that sat uneasily with the world as it was. I was already interested in poverty in Canada, not as an abstraction but as a lived condition shaped by institutions, language, history and policy. At the same time, I was absorbing existential philosophy through doctoral-level courses at York University, trying to understand how meaning is constructed, how experience precedes explanation, and how people live inside structures they did not design. I flamed out before getting my PhD because I had - somewhat later - come to the point where I could not stand the thought of sitting in a classroom listening to anything about anything. Twenty-two may be too…
Read More

The prize the Boomers won: Things can never be better, right?

Blog
It has become almost axiomatic to say that the Baby Boomers won the economic lottery. They bought houses decades ago that are now worth many multiples of what they paid. They invested in markets that rose far beyond what anyone in 1980 could have reasonably forecast. A house bought for $100,000 that is now worth $1.2 million. A stock market that has turned early investments into forty- or fifty-baggers. These facts are real, and denying them only weakens the argument that follows. But facts are not the same as conclusions. And what has quietly hardened into orthodoxy is not simply that Boomers did well, but that no subsequent generation can possibly do as well. That belief now functions as an article of faith. Inheritors, not creators The so-called Greatest Generation…
Read More

Income taxation: The part of seniors’ income security we never talk about

Blog
We have grown accustomed to talking about seniors almost exclusively on the spending side of the ledger. Old Age Security is framed as a looming fiscal burden. CPP benefits are treated as obligations inherited by younger generations. Demographics are invoked as destiny, and aging is presented as a problem to be managed. What is rarely discussed—almost never quantified—is the other half of the equation: how much income tax governments collect from seniors themselves. Income tax collected from seniors Canadians over 65 now pay income tax on nearly every major source of retirement income. Old Age Security is taxable. CPP is taxable. Employer pensions are taxable. RRIF withdrawals are fully taxable. This is not a marginal phenomenon; it is the core architecture of retirement income in Canada. When you aggregate the…
Read More

Evidence, framing, and the  importance of deconstruction: understanding the polarization effects of video through an advocacy lens

Blog
The recent Minneapolis shooting of a 37-year-old mother, captured on video and circulated almost immediately, should have been a case where evidence narrowed disagreement. Instead, it became a case study in how the same visual record can sustain radically different interpretations, each internally coherent, each morally charged, and each largely impervious to rebuttal. This is not because the video is unclear. It is because evidence does not arrive naked. It arrives already clothed in assumptions, categories, and expectations. What we are witnessing is not a dispute about facts, but a clash between interpretive protocols—systems for deciding what counts as threat, intent, innocence, or justification before the evidence is even assessed. Watching news commentators questioning interpretation is painful because they at least appear to fail to fully understand that what we…
Read More

Evidence should constrain us -it most often does not

Blog
We tend to describe the deterioration of news and research reporting along with political decision-making crises of polarization, misinformation, or declining trust. Those diagnoses are not wrong, but they are incomplete. Beneath them lies a deeper problem: the steady normalization of decision-based evidence making, enabled by a widespread collapse in critical thinking skills that were once explicitly taught and socially enforced. All the reasons for the collapse of critical thinking have been written about ad nauseam. I shall not repeat them here. My point here is that  we have not entered an era without evidence. We have more now than we have ever had with new ways through AI to analyse it.  But we have entered an era in which evidence is unmoored from method and its philosophical roots as…
Read More

When Evidence Loses Its  origins and generation: What tomorrow’s archeologists might discover about the 2020’s

Blog
We often describe our moment in history as one in which evidence is ignored, denied, or suppressed. That diagnosis is comforting. It suggests that the problem lies with bad actors who reject facts. What is more troubling—and more accurate—is that evidence is everywhere, but its origins and methods of generation – its grammars – have been lost. In short, we have not stopped using evidence. We have stopped thinking with it. In an earlier essay, I argued that much of public life now operates through decision-based evidence making: decisions are reached first, then justified retroactively by whatever data, anecdote, correlation, or expert view can be made to fit. What has become clearer since is that this practice is sustained not merely by cynicism or ideology, but by a widespread collapse…
Read More