From “No car, no radio” to engineered scarcity: The changing face of welfare isolation
In 1998, Margaret Hillyard Little published No Car, No Radio, No Liquor Permit: The Moral Regulation of Single Mothers in Ontario, 1920–1997. Drawing on archival records and interviews, she documented how Ontario’s mothers’ allowance (welfare) system explicitly monitored and regulated single mothers. Eligibility was not merely financial; it was moral. Caseworkers inspected homes. Cars were forbidden. Radios were deemed luxuries. Liquor permits were denied. Telephones were suspect. Your way to hear from the world, talk to the world and get to the world were all forbidden. Relief came with isolation. The message was unambiguous: assistance must not resemble belonging. James Struthers, in The Limits of Affluence, similarly showed how Canadian social policy was shaped by an enduring caution. Aid was necessary, but it must remain less attractive than independence. Isolation…
