From “No car, no radio” to engineered scarcity: The changing face of welfare isolation

Blog
In 1998, Margaret Hillyard Little published No Car, No Radio, No Liquor Permit: The Moral Regulation of Single Mothers in Ontario, 1920–1997. Drawing on archival records and interviews, she documented how Ontario’s mothers’ allowance (welfare) system explicitly monitored and regulated single mothers. Eligibility was not merely financial; it was moral. Caseworkers inspected homes. Cars were forbidden. Radios were deemed luxuries. Liquor permits were denied. Telephones were suspect. Your way to hear from the world, talk to the world and get to the world were all forbidden. Relief came with isolation. The message was unambiguous: assistance must not resemble belonging. James Struthers, in The Limits of Affluence, similarly showed how Canadian social policy was shaped by an enduring caution. Aid was necessary, but it must remain less attractive than independence. Isolation…
Read More

Life course thresholds: The inflection points of care we seldom hear about

Blog
Modern health literature is saturated with advice. Eat better.Drink more water.Exercise daily.Maintain grip strength.Reduce alcohol.Stop smoking.Prevent falls. The genre is endless and reassuring. It assumes that decline is negotiable — that with sufficient vigilance, discipline and compliance, deterioration can be deferred indefinitely. There is truth in this. Prevention matters. Diet and exercise change outcomes. Smoking cessation works. Public health victories are real. But what we rarely discuss are the moments when prevention gives way to thresholds. There are inflection points in aging and illness that are not about optimization. They are about transition. And these transitions are precisely where caregiving begins in earnest, where homes must be altered or abandoned, where autonomy changes from assumption to negotiation. We write extensively about avoiding these moments. We write very little about recognizing…
Read More

Beyond the needle, Part 3: When skepticism hardens and institutions overpromise

Blog
The public argument about vaccines is rarely about vaccines alone. It is about trust. It is about who defines credible evidence. And it is about what happens when institutional confidence thins. Regulatory capture To understand the appeal of vaccine skepticism associated with figures like Robert F. Kennedy Jr., we have to begin in an uncomfortable place: with the plausibility of its starting point. The starting point is regulatory capture. Pharmaceutical companies are powerful. Regulators rely on industry-generated data. Revolving doors exist. In other sectors — opioids, finance, environmental regulation — oversight has visibly failed. In that context, suspicion toward regulatory assurances does not sound absurd. It sounds cautious. From that premise, a chain of reasoning follows: If regulators are compromised, and vaccine safety depends on regulators, then vaccine assurances deserve…
Read More

The Beagle, Peas, Northern Dancer and Secretariat: what Darwin and Mendel’s solitary work can still teach us about theory and practice

Blog
This essay concerns itself with schools of thought that initially did not engage each other  but eventually met both informally and formally. The formal meeting took place through modern genetic and evolutionary thinking. The earlier yet informal meeting is exemplified through the thoroughbred horse breeding of Federico Tesio.   If  Darwin and Mendel’s thinking had met earlier and fluently, we would have possibly avoided the scourge of Eugenics. The fact that they did meet before the theoretical bridge had been built between them gives us the modern thoroughbred horse through Federico Tesio – both Northern Dancer and Secretariat. It’s an interesting story in two parts. Part 1: Darwin and Mendel I have a deep interest in Darwin and Mendel. Over the last year, I traveled to South America twice –…
Read More

Beyond the needle, Part 2: If vaccines work, why doesn’t that settle the argument?

Blog
Much of what follows draws on well-known public health history and behavioural research, but the failure to integrate these insights has left vaccine debates stuck in the wrong register. And one of the frustrations in the vaccine debate is that both sides are, in a narrow sense, correct. Vaccines do work. The evidence is overwhelming. They reduce severe disease, hospitalization, and death. They train the immune system to recognize novel pathogens before those pathogens can overwhelm the body. This is not controversial science; it is settled biology, visible in everything from smallpox eradication to the differential outcomes of COVID-19 across populations. And yet, large numbers of people who are not ignorant, not conspiratorial, and not hostile to science still resist vaccination. Puzzlingly, many of them acknowledge that vaccines work —…
Read More

When “restraint-free care” becomes a moral fiction

Blog
Ontario’s long-term care and retirement-care frameworks are built around a powerful moral claim: restraint is a last resort, autonomy must be preserved, and dignity requires the least restrictive environment possible. These principles are sound in the vast majority of cases. They emerged in response to real historical abuses, and they have rightly reshaped practice across the system. But policy failure does not always occur at the centre of a distribution. It can happen at its edge. There is a small, rarely acknowledged but growing category of dementia cases where Ontario’s current framework stops protecting dignity and starts protecting a narrative — a narrative that says restraint has been solved, risk can be managed, and autonomy can always be honoured if only we try hard enough. My mother reached that edge.…
Read More

Beyond the needle: Why vaccine hesitancy persists — and what it would take to depolarize the debate

Blog
Public debate about vaccines usually begins at the wrong level. It starts with moral judgments (“anti-science,” “irresponsible,” “misinformed”) rather than with an examination of how people actually reason about bodies, risk, evidence, and trust. Once framed that way, the debate hardens. One side defends science. The other defends autonomy. And neither side feels understood. Vaccine hesitancy is not best understood as ignorance or conspiracy thinking. It is better understood as a collision between population-level reasoning and individual-level experience—between how public health evaluates risk and how human beings live inside it. To move beyond the needle, we need to understand what people are objecting to, what kind of evidence they find unconvincing, and why reassurance so often backfires. Personal boundaries “Foreign matter” is not a scientific claim — it is a…
Read More

When policy arguments play the ‘Shell Game’

Blog
There is a familiar move in public debate that feels persuasive without ever quite settling into proof. It borrows the language of fairness, cites real numbers, and nods respectfully toward compassion. But the core question keeps shifting just as you think you’ve grasped it. By the time you reach the conclusion, something important has happened: you feel convinced without being sure of what, exactly, you’ve been shown. This is the intellectual equivalent of the carnival shell game. In the classic shell game (sorry: annoying video but he does explain it): There is one real object (the pea). The operator moves the shells, not the pea. The mark is encouraged to follow motion, not substance. The trick succeeds not through lying, but through misdirection and speed. At no point is the…
Read More

When “perception of abuse” replaces evidence: A reflection on refugees, claimants, and a renewed invitation to prejudice

Blog
Robyn Urback’s argument for scaling back refugee health coverage under the Interim Federal Health Program (IFHP) rests on a familiar move in contemporary policy debate: the substitution of perception for evidence, and the quiet collapse of crucial distinctions that the law, the data, and basic fairness insist we keep separate. Her piece is careful, almost lawyerly, in tone. It cites numbers. It invokes cost-of-living pressures. It nods to compassion before turning to restraint. But beneath that surface is a conceptual sleight of hand that matters enormously for public policy: repeated equivocation between refugee claimants and refugees, and an unexamined appeal to what she twice calls the public “perception” that Canada’s refugee system is being abused. Refugees and refugee claimants Let’s start with the distinction she blurs. Refugee claimants are applicants.…
Read More

“Is that one of ours?”

Blog
It happened in Montevideo, in the way small moments often do—casually, unselfconsciously, and therefore in a revealing way. A fellow passenger on a cruise, an American, had just finished admonishing a street vendor for not returning her change in U.S. dollars. She turned toward the harbour, pointed at what appeared to be a military ship—grey, angular, carrying the unmistakable silhouette of weaponry—and asked me, without hesitation or irony: “Is that one of ours?” I paused, not because I lacked an answer, but because the question itself seemed to require unpacking before it could be answered at all. Whose ours? Assumptions The question assumed several things at once. It assumed I was American. It assumed that nationality was audible. It assumed that Americans, wherever they go, are surrounded by other Americans…
Read More