Waiting 117 years to collect a fictional $10.3 billion pandemic debt

Blog
 CBC Newsworld recently ran a ribbon announcing that Canadians still owe Ottawa $10.3 billion in pandemic benefits. The number has been repeated so often that it has acquired the authority of an established fact. Canadians received money they were not entitled to, the government discovered the problem, and now the money must be returned. It is a wonderfully simple story. Unfortunately, the simplicity is largely a CRA construction. The $10.3 billion is not an independently established measure of money Canadians wrongly received and retained. It is the accumulated product of decisions made by the agency that administered the benefits, reviewed eligibility, established debts and pursued repayment. CRA has counted what CRA decided was owing, and the resulting total is presented to the public as proof that the money is owed.…
Read More

Glacier collapse: When knowing is not enough

Blog
The story of smong is about knowledge surviving through time. On the Indonesian island of Simeulue, the memory of a devastating 1907 tsunami was passed from one generation to another as a simple lesson: when the earth shakes and the sea suddenly withdraws, go to high ground. Nearly a century later, that knowledge saved lives during the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. It is an extraordinary example of a society successfully preserving what it had learned. But there is another problem with human knowledge that may be just as important. Sometimes we have not forgotten the lesson. We possess enormous amounts of relevant knowledge, but it is scattered among different people, disciplines, governments and technologies. The problem is not remembering it. The problem is assembling it and getting it to the…
Read More

When the sea goes out

Blog
What nuclear winter, a tsunami and two reactors meltdowns can teach us about artificial intelligence There are moments when humanity discovers a danger before experiencing its worst possible version. Those moments present us with an unusual problem. We have evidence, but not the final evidence. We know enough to be frightened, but the catastrophe that would settle the argument has not happened. What are we supposed to do then? Artificial intelligence may be bringing us to such a moment. Dario Amodei, the head of Anthropic and hardly an outsider to the development of artificial intelligence, has now called for the development of AI to slow down. His concern is not simply that AI occasionally gives a wrong answer or that people may lose jobs. He points to something potentially much…
Read More

Deconstructing conversations about vaccines – A policy wonk’s guide to vaccination

Blog
I have been thinking about the way we talk to people who do not believe in vaccination. We usually begin with the vaccine. We tell them how effective it is, quote studies, explain the risks and point to what happened to disease rates after vaccines were introduced. When that does not persuade, frustration sets in. Before long, one side is talking about ignorance and misinformation while the other is talking about freedom, government and pharmaceutical companies. Perhaps we are starting in the wrong place. Suppose instead that we started with something on which almost everyone can agree: the human body is astonishingly good at looking after itself. Cut your finger and, most of the time, you do not have to tell your body what to do. Blood clots, new tissue…
Read More

The safest thing to do on welfare is nothing

Blog
Social assistance says it wants people to become more active and independent. Work a few hours. Take some training. Try self-employment. Share accommodation. Form relationships. Accept help from family. Save a little money. Find cheaper housing. Travel to improve opportunity. Participate in the community. Improve your circumstances. Then try doing any of those things. Earn some money and the system wants to know about it—not simply because it is interested in your progress, but because some of that income may reduce your benefits. Receive an honorarium and it has to be classified. Get help from family and the system may want to know whether it is a gift, income or continuing support. Change your living arrangements and questions arise about who lives with you, what they contribute and the nature…
Read More

We still need to know which way to run – the lesson of smong

Blog
When the Indian Ocean tsunami struck in 2004, some people saw the sea suddenly retreat and went down to look. Others ran. On the Indonesian island of Simeulue, people remembered smong, an oral tradition handed down after a devastating tsunami in 1907. The story carried a simple instruction across generations: if the earth shakes and the sea withdraws, get to high ground. In 2004, that inherited knowledge saved lives. It is a remarkable example of something human beings have been doing since before writing. We experience something, learn from it and try to prevent the lesson from dying with us. But we are not particularly good at it. Languages disappear. Oral traditions vanish. Libraries burn. Technologies are forgotten. Political ideas go out of fashion and are rediscovered generations later under…
Read More

Why don’t we let people on welfare work together?

Blog
There are many things we tell people on welfare to do that we don't actually make very easy for them to do. It belongs with the others I have been writing about: Get a job. Get some training. Save some money. Get help from your family. Find someone to share the rent with. Travel if that is what ordinary family life or opportunity requires. These are all perfectly normal things for the rest of us to do. In fact, they are mostly things we associate with becoming more independent. But there is another one that I think goes even deeper. Relying on other people. We don't usually say that one out loud. In fact, welfare programs tend to say almost exactly the opposite. Their great objective is “self-reliance.” The person…
Read More

The ‘secret’ that welfare recipients know

Blog
There is a ‘secret’ about welfare that almost everyone who has spent time receiving Ontario Works understands. ODSP recipients too, know it well. It is not a secret because anyone is deliberately concealing it. It is a secret because the people who know it rarely get to design the system, explain it to the public, or frame the political debate. The secret is remarkably simple: Many of the actions we tell people on welfare they should undertake to become independent are the very things the welfare system penalizes them for doing. Get a job. Get some training. Accept help from your family. Find someone to share the rent. Save some money so the next emergency doesn't become a catastrophe. These are not radical ideas. They are the standard Canadian prescription…
Read More

We are asking the wrong question about tariffs and trade

Blog
Before asking when America last treated Canada this way, ask what the purpose of tariffs used to be before the advent of income taxation News reporters keep asking historians and economists a seemingly straightforward question about the latest American tariffs on Canada: When has the United States ever done this to us before? William McKinley usually appears somewhere in the answer. The United States imposed very high tariffs in the late nineteenth century. McKinley championed the famous tariff bearing his name in 1890, and as president remained a committed protectionist. Mr. Trump sounds like he wants to go back to the days of McKinley. In his February 24, 2026 State of the Union address, Trump said: “As time goes by, I believe the tariffs paid for by foreign countries will,…
Read More

The Paul Simon songs Malcolm Gladwell missed?

Blog
I have just listened to Miracle and Wonder, Malcolm Gladwell and Bruce Headlam’s extraordinary audio portrait of Paul Simon. It is based on some 30 hours of conversation with Simon and sets itself the ambitious task of understanding how someone from Queens could produce “near-perfect songs” over a career of more than six decades. I enjoyed it enormously. But I kept waiting. Gladwell naturally spends time on the monuments: The Sound of Silence, The Boxer, Bridge Over Troubled Water, Graceland. They belong in any account of Paul Simon. But chapter after chapter, I waited for my Paul Simon to turn up. I was 16 when I first heard 'Like a Rock' - a song hardly mentioned - Gladwell was 7 when he first heard Bridge over Troubled Water -discussed in…
Read More