CERB, welfare clawbacks and the modern degradation ceremony. How Cool Hand Luke and Harold Garfinkel help explain the CERB aftermath

Blog
Sociologist Harold Garfinkel developed the concept of the “degradation ceremony” to describe institutional rituals that transform a person from a legitimate member of society into a suspect, deviant, or morally diminished figure. The purpose is not merely punishment. It is social instruction. The individual becomes an example through which institutions reaffirm the moral order. Viewed through this lens, the aftermath of pandemic benefits paid to individuals and welfare clawbacks begins to look less like administrative housekeeping and more like a modern bureaucratic degradation ceremony aimed disproportionately at the poor. At the beginning of the pandemic, governments urgently encouraged Canadians to apply for emergency benefits. CERB was delivered at unprecedented speed because governments feared economic collapse and social panic. The message was simple: stay home, stay safe, apply if you need…
Read More

Nobody planned three decades of decline

Blog
Nobody sat down at Queen's Park in 1995 and decided that Ontario should spend the next thirty-one years progressively reducing the real value of welfare for its poorest residents. Mike Harris's decision was certainly deliberate. His government cut the rate for a single person by more than 21 per cent, from $663 to $520 a month. What happened afterward was different. The Harris government did not increase the rate again. Neither did Ernie Eves. Liberal governments gradually increased it from $520 to $733 between 2003 and 2018, but never restored what had been lost in real terms. Doug Ford has left the Ontario Works rate at $733 since taking office. The remarkable part of this history is not simply the decline of 43-44% in the rates. It is that no…
Read More

This expensive business of keeping people poor

Blog
There is a question Ontario rarely asks about poverty. It is not whether we can afford to raise Ontario Works, whether food banks need more money, whether municipalities need another homelessness program, or whether employment services need better case management. The more fundamental question is this: How long can Ontario afford to maintain a system in which inadequate primary income support continually creates demand for secondary systems to manage the consequences? We have become remarkably inventive at treating the symptoms of inadequate income while remaining strangely incurious about the cost of creating those symptoms. Consider Ontario Works. A single person can receive a maximum of $733 a month for basic needs and shelter, an amount that has not increased since 2018. Try living on it. Then watch what happens. The…
Read More

One point of view and one only: the ‘gas pump TV news ritual’

Blog
We have all seen the television news item. Gasoline prices have jumped overnight. A reporter is dispatched to a filling station. The camera finds someone standing beside an SUV watching the numbers spin upward on the pump. "How is this affecting you?" The answers are remarkably predictable. "It's getting ridiculous." "I'll have to cut back somewhere." "We won't be taking as many trips." "Everything is getting so expensive." “I can’t fill my tank – I can’t afford it” Then another motorist says essentially the same thing. Perhaps a third is interviewed for confirmation. And the story is complete. I have wondered for years why virtually nobody at these gas pumps ever says anything else. Where is the motorist who says: "I don't like paying more, but perhaps gasoline has been…
Read More

High food costs in the north. The price of a stamp vs. the price of milk

Blog
When teaching public policy, I often describe choices along a continuum. Take the high cost of food in Canada's North. At one end, government could do nothing and leave northern residents to absorb the higher cost themselves. Moving along the income support continuum, it could provide increasingly generous income supplements to low-income households. At the far end, it could provide enough additional income to compensate fully for the difference between northern and southern food prices. Those are all variations of the same policy. We change the amount of assistance in line with income support solutions But good policy analysis should always ask another question: Could we do something different that had similar results? Income solutions can almost always solve high-cost issues but are not always the best way to deal…
Read More

Non-stop eligibility reporting for the poor: Well-managed poverty in Canada’s Administration State

Blog
“Once verification of ineligibility and overpayment is provided, social assistance eligibility should be reassessed based on any new or changed circumstances. A reassessment requires that any other change in circumstance also be assessed. For example, in some cases people must repay the CERB because they returned to work earlier than expected. In these cases, any earned income received that had not previously been recorded (along with any other change in the person’s circumstances e.g. shelter) must be considered. In all cases, the CERB/CESB overpayment is attributed to the benefit month(s) where the payment was originally charged.” ODSP directive from 2020 found on Reddit For most of the twentieth century, Canada judged its social programs by a fairly simple standard: Did they improve people's lives? Old Age Security was designed to…
Read More

When the gateway costs more than the gate

Blog
A sequel to "The Disability Tax Credit Was Never Meant to Carry This Much Weight" My first essay argued that the Disability Tax Credit (DTC) has evolved from a modest, non-refundable tax credit into Canada's principal federal definition of disability.  That institutional change has another consequence that deserves attention. The fiscal consequences of DTC eligibility are no longer confined to the tax system. They now extend deep into federal program spending. That changes everything. When Finance Canada estimates the cost of the Disability Tax Credit, it records the revenue forgone from the tax credit itself. Today that tax expenditure is on the order of $2 billion annually. But that figure no longer tells the real fiscal story. The DTC has become the gateway to a growing list of federal expenditures…
Read More

The Disability Tax Credit was never meant to carry this much weight

Blog
The Income Tax Act is an odd place to define disability. We do not define old age through the Income Tax Act before someone can receive Old Age Security. We do not define unemployment through the Income Tax Act before someone qualifies for Employment Insurance. Yet disability—uniquely—has become anchored in a provision originally designed to reduce income tax for people who owed income tax. That solved some administrative problems but has created a whole host of policy issues. Now, the Disability Tax Credit (DTC) has become one of the most important pieces of disability policy in Canada. That was never its intended purpose. The DTC was created as a non-refundable income tax credit. It was designed to answer a straightforward tax policy question: ‘Should a taxpayer with severe disabilities pay…
Read More

Canada Doesn’t Need a Fire Czar. It Needs a National Voice.

Blog
As Canada's wildfire seasons become longer and more destructive, a familiar proposal keeps resurfacing: appoint a national fire czar. The idea has appeal. Canadians want to know someone is in charge. But many wildfire professionals push back. They argue that the best decisions are made close to the fire, not in Ottawa. Local incident commanders understand the terrain, the weather, the fuels, the communities at risk and the resources available. Another level of bureaucracy risks slowing decisions that often need to be made in minutes. They have a point. Yet those calling for stronger national leadership also have a point. The mistake is assuming these are the same job. Canada does not need one person in Ottawa directing every wildfire response. It does need someone Canadians trust to explain what…
Read More

When success doesn’t feel like success…. Is donor fatigue also a crisis of confidence?

Blog
Everyone knows one reason charitable giving has declined. Life has become more expensive. Families have less disposable income. When budgets tighten, donations are often among the first expenses to be reduced. But perhaps there is another reason that receives far less attention. Perhaps donors are beginning to wonder whether all of this effort is actually changing anything. Every year charities publish impressive annual reports. I have said this before: More meals served. More families assisted. More people housed. More counselling sessions. More tax returns completed. The numbers are real. The work is real. The dedication is beyond question. Yet when donors step outside their front door, they often see something quite different. Food bank lines continue to grow. Homelessness has become more visible. People with disabilities continue living far below…
Read More