When did a photograph become proof of consultation?

Blog
At a City of Toronto budget consultation last year in Scarborough, I noticed something curious. Staff members circulated through the room taking photographs. Participants sat in groups discussing city priorities. Somewhere near the entrance was a sign indicating that by attending we consented to being photographed. At the time, I thought little of it. Later, however, I began seeing many of those photographs online. There were pictures of residents gathered around tables, people speaking into microphones, small groups in discussion, staff facilitating conversations. The message was unmistakable: Consultation was happening. Or was it? The experience left me wondering whether we have quietly redefined what consultation means. Presence vs participation Traditionally, consultation was judged by outcomes. Residents were invited to participate because their views might influence decisions. The important questions were…
Read More

A top 50 list of counterpoints against cutting OAS

Blog
This is a list to counter ‘cut OAS to help the young’ articles. Some arguments are fiscal, some are conceptual, some are political. Together they amount to a comprehensive critique. The five most powerful arguments are:   > The problem is wealth - the proposed solution targets income.   > OAS is analyzed in gross terms, not net terms after taxes and clawbacks.   > The denominator is manipulated by using federal program spending rather than broader measures.   > OAS is being criticized because it succeeded in reducing senior poverty.   > The fixation on OAS may be a substitute for a serious discussion about wealth concentration, inheritances, housing gains, and asset inequality.   These five together probably dismantle 80% of the contemporary ‘cut OAS for intergenerational fairness’ literature.…
Read More

The wrong target: Why cutting OAS will not solve intergenerational inequality

Blog
Canada's debate over intergenerational fairness is increasingly focused on Old Age Security. Proposals from Senator Andrew Cardozo and Generation Squeeze founder Paul Kershaw to reduce OAS payments for seniors with higher household incomes call for government to redirect the savings toward younger Canadians facing unemployment and economic insecurity. The concern is legitimate. Young Canadians face extraordinary challenges. Housing costs have exploded. Stable employment has become harder to find. Student debt remains significant. Many young adults are postponing family formation and wealth accumulation. Governments should absolutely do more to support younger generations. But the proposed solution reveals a growing weakness in Canada's public policy debate. It confuses income with wealth. And because of that confusion, it risks weakening one of Canada's most successful income security programs while doing little to address…
Read More

Why do some politicians get so angry about welfare?

Blog
“There’s a growing impression among the taxpayers of this province that they are being drained of their money to provide a living for idlers.” — Mitch Hepburn, 1935 “We had to create ‘get-off-your-duff-and-do-something fare.’” — Mike Harris, 2002 “It really bothers me that we have healthy people sitting at home collecting your hard-earned dollars.” — Doug Ford, 2023 Three premiers. Nearly ninety years apart. All won majorities. All won re-election. Yet all were animated by the same question: What are poor people doing all day? The persistence of this concern is remarkable. Economic conditions changed. Governments changed. Welfare rules changed. Yet the emotional tone remained surprisingly constant. Why the concern? The obvious explanation is fiscal concern. Politicians worry about public spending. But that explanation quickly falls apart. If the issue…
Read More

If we all agree on the path out of poverty, why does welfare block it?

Blog
“There’s a growing impression among the taxpayers of this province that they are being drained of their money to provide a living for idlers… We will pay the municipalities a lump sum each month… In other words, we will say to them: 'Here’s the alimony, you raise the children.'” – Mitch Hepburn, Premier of Ontario, 1935 “There was rampant fraud and welfare abuse… it was inconvenient for people to have to go down to offices to pick up cheques so we mailed them out and we found out that mail was being re-directed to other provinces and even other countries…We had to re-adjust rates and give incentives for those who were able-bodied to go out and get into what we called ‘workfare’ or ‘education fare’ or ‘get-off-your-duff-and do-something fare.’ So,…
Read More

If intergenerational equity is about wealth, why are we arguing about Old Age Security?

Blog
Few ideas have gained more traction in Canadian public policy circles than intergenerational equity. The argument is familiar. Younger Canadians face soaring housing costs, delayed family formation, stagnant productivity growth, and declining economic security. Meanwhile, older Canadians are portrayed as a protected class receiving public pensions, benefiting from rising home values, and consuming an increasing share of public resources. There is truth in some of these observations. But there is a profound problem with the policy response that often follows. Wealth vs income Canada keeps debating seniors' income while largely ignoring wealth. As a result, much of the discussion about intergenerational fairness ends up missing the issue almost entirely. Consider a simple fact. Almost every major income security program in Canada reaches some wealthy recipients. Millionaires receive CPP. Millionaires receive…
Read More

When poverty becomes an emergency: Why first responders are carrying the burden of income insecurity

Blog
Across Canada, first responders increasingly find themselves responding not to emergencies in the traditional sense, but to the predictable consequences of poverty. Police officers respond to mental-health crises rooted in housing instability and deprivation. Paramedics are called repeatedly to rooming houses, shelters, encampments, and apartments where chronic illness has been made worse by poverty. Emergency departments treat people whose conditions deteriorated because they could not afford food, transportation, medications, dental care, or stable housing. Firefighters are dispatched to overcrowded housing, unsafe heating arrangements, and buildings whose occupants have nowhere else to go. None of this reflects a failure of first responders. It reflects a failure of social architecture. The impact of the shift from income security Over the past three decades, Canada has gradually shifted away from stable income security…
Read More

Does emergency intervention cost more than income security? You bet it does.

Blog
Beginning in the early 1990s, something fundamental changed in Canada’s approach to poverty and income insecurity. For decades after the Second World War, Canada had gradually constructed a layered income security system. It was incomplete and often inadequate, but the underlying direction was broadly clear: governments were expected to provide stable social infrastructure capable of preventing severe economic insecurity before crisis emerged. Then the architecture began to shift. The erosion of income support One crucial turning point came in 1990 when the federal government capped cost-sharing under the Canada Assistance Plan (CAP) for Ontario, British Columbia, and Alberta. CAP had been imperfect, but it established an important national principle: the federal government shared responsibility for social assistance and provinces were required to meet certain conditions in return for federal funding.…
Read More

Income security vs. constant emergency intervention: Is stability a radical choice?

Blog
For much of the postwar era, Canada’s social architecture rested on a relatively simple idea: governments should build systems sturdy enough to prevent widespread economic insecurity before crisis emerges. The tools varied. Family allowances, Unemployment insurance, Old Age Security, The Guaranteed Income Supplement, social assistance, public pensions, refundable tax credits, housing supports, and Medicare. Some programs worked better than others, and many left major gaps. But the underlying philosophy was broadly consistent. The state was expected to provide predictable, rules-based systems that reduced the likelihood of social and economic collapse in the first place. Over time, that philosophy changed. Canada did not entirely abandon income security. But it increasingly replaced long-term structural adequacy with episodic emergency management. The shift happened gradually enough that many Canadians barely noticed it. We still…
Read More

What happens to welfare work requirements under AI and the redefinition of work?

Blog
For most of human history, work was visible. A farmer plowed a field. A blacksmith shaped iron. A dockworker lifted cargo. A seamstress stitched fabric. Even early industrial labour, however brutal, retained a certain material clarity. Work involved observable physical effort transforming the physical world. Then something changed. Over the course of the twentieth century, advanced economies slowly detached the idea of work from visible material production. Increasingly, work became administrative, symbolic, managerial, communicative, and digital. Millions of people now spend their working lives moving information rather than objects. And now artificial intelligence may be destabilizing the very definition of work itself. What is work? Much of the current discussion around AI focuses on job loss. Will accountants disappear? Lawyers? Graphic designers? Coders? Teachers? Journalists? The anxiety is understandable, but…
Read More