When did a photograph become proof of consultation?
At a City of Toronto budget consultation last year in Scarborough, I noticed something curious. Staff members circulated through the room taking photographs. Participants sat in groups discussing city priorities. Somewhere near the entrance was a sign indicating that by attending we consented to being photographed. At the time, I thought little of it. Later, however, I began seeing many of those photographs online. There were pictures of residents gathered around tables, people speaking into microphones, small groups in discussion, staff facilitating conversations. The message was unmistakable: Consultation was happening. Or was it? The experience left me wondering whether we have quietly redefined what consultation means. Presence vs participation Traditionally, consultation was judged by outcomes. Residents were invited to participate because their views might influence decisions. The important questions were…
