When success hides failure – a poverty reduction conundrum

Blog
There is a paradox at the heart of Canada's social sector that we rarely acknowledge. The organizations doing the most good may also be making it easier for governments to avoid solving the problems they exist to address. That is not because charities, foundations and community agencies are doing anything wrong. Quite the opposite. They are staffed by dedicated people who improve lives every day. They feed hungry families, keep people housed, help people file their taxes, connect isolated seniors, and support people with disabilities. Society would be immeasurably poorer without them. But they operate within a system that rewards success in ways that can unintentionally hide failure. Every organization depends on someone for funding. Governments. Foundations. Corporate donors. Individual donors. To survive, they must demonstrate impact. Annual reports celebrate…
Read More

Income adequacy advocacy has fragmented – while too many believe need has been met

Blog
For thirty years, governments in Canada have carefully stepped away from a responsibility they once openly accepted. There was a time when governments at least claimed responsibility for ensuring that the most vulnerable people in society had enough income to survive. Today that commitment has become increasingly difficult to find. Provincial welfare rates have experienced a long-term decline (33 years long in Ontario) in real value. Cost-sharing arrangements between senior governments disappeared around the same time. The public conversation now rarely focuses on income adequacy. Few politicians speak passionately about ensuring that social assistance provides enough to live on. Yet something remarkable has happened. The political consequences have been surprisingly limited. Why? Because as governments retreated, others stepped forward. Food banks expanded. Housing and homelessness organizations and their advocacy expanded.…
Read More

What death notices understand about the economy

Blog
Every Saturday I do something that may surprise people. I turn to the Business sections of the print newspapers to which I subscribe. Not first to the markets. Not to Bay Street. Not to the latest GDP figures. I turn to the death notices – the obituaries or obits. And over many years I have noticed something curious. The Business section is filled with stories celebrating productivity, economic growth, investment, mergers, corporate performance and wealth creation. Turn a few pages and you encounter something entirely different. Lives. The death notices follow a remarkably consistent pattern. We learn where someone was born; who their parents were; the siblings they loved; the children and grandchildren they cherished. We read about cottages, sailboats, curling clubs, volunteer work, bridge games, favourite fishing spots and…
Read More

Living through an unexpected loss of $123.65 – Why people with disabilities lose benefits when they don’t stay home

Blog
“Every breath you take And every move you make….Every step you takeI'll be watching youEvery single day….And every word you say Every night you stayI'll be watching you”  Every Breath You Take Synchronicity The Police 1983 A friend of mine recently travelled from Ontario to Nova Scotia. Not for a vacation. His stepfather had died unexpectedly. His elderly mother needed help. He did exactly what the Ontario Disability Support Program requires. Before leaving, he informed his caseworker that he was going. He explained that he had purchased a one-way ticket - with the help of his family - because he did not know how long his mother would need him. He promised to report back once he had booked his return passage. His caseworker expressed sympathy for his loss and simply…
Read More

Not a Cinderella story: RRSP carriages turn into RRIF pumpkins

Blog
Most Canadians have heard of RRSPs turning into RRIFs but fewer understand RRIFs. And fewer still understand how a RRIF can become a costly surprise for low-income seniors. We have already published the parable of Cinderella and the three gifts of retirement. Now let's unpack this historically and analytically: 1957: The RRSP is born The RRSP was introduced in 1957. The idea was straightforward: encourage Canadians to save for retirement by allowing them to deduct contributions from taxable income and defer tax until later. They earn RRSP room generally at 18% of their wages. 1978: The RRIF joins the family Twenty-one years later in 1978, the RRIF arrived. As in the folk tale Cinderella, something unwelcome happens at the stroke of a particular midnight and there is a policy-based curfew.…
Read More

Snakes and Ladders is a game: Ontario Works should not be playing it

Blog
Many years ago, at a conference in Vancouver, a woman described her experience in Ontario's Basic Income Pilot. She had previously been receiving Ontario Works. What she remembered most wasn't the amount of money. It was something much simpler. She said that while receiving Ontario Works, she had been "kicked off" assistance around fifty times as she tried to work over many years. Under the Basic Income Pilot, that stopped happening. That one observation has stayed with me ever since. How much can an Ontario Works recipient earn before they aren't eligible? For many years I conducted full-day workshops with Ontario Works and ODSP recipients in Toronto. Together, we would calculate something almost nobody knew—not the recipients, not many workers, and often not community agencies. How much could each person…
Read More

Cinderella and the three gifts of retirement in Canada

Blog
The bedrock of Canada’s retirement income system is OAS, CPP and a pension. But there are three other important elements of the system: The RRSP, the RRIF, and the TFSA. The following is a parable that explains how they work for rich and poor, Cinderella's story Once upon a time, in a constitutional monarchy called Canada, there lived a young woman named Cinderella. She worked very hard. Every morning, she scrubbed floors, carried water, washed clothes and did whatever honest work she could find. She never earned very much, but she earned enough that the Prime Minister took notice. "He who works should be encouraged to save," he proclaimed. RRSPs So, in 1957, the Prime Minister summoned the Fairy Godmother—known throughout the kingdom as the Queen of Canada—and asked her…
Read More

When identity politics meets intergenerational equity

Blog
One of the great ironies of modern public policy is that many of the people who criticize identity politics seem to have adopted one of its central assumptions. The assumption is simple: If we know which group someone belongs to, we know something important about their interests. Mistaking age for advantage For years we have heard politics discussed through the lenses of race, gender, ethnicity, religion, geography, and culture. Increasingly, however, another identity has entered the conversation and that is generation:  young people/millennials vs boomers/seniors. Generation Squeeze has been enormously successful in drawing attention to the challenges facing younger Canadians. Housing affordability, student debt, precarious work, and the rising cost of raising children are real issues. They deserve serious attention. But there is a growing risk that the policy discussion…
Read More

The World Cup and the new age of the short performative outburst

Blog
I have never been much of a soccer fan. Like many Canadians, I grew up on hockey and Canadian football. I can appreciate great athletes, but I have never followed (soccer) football closely. Yet watching Canada compete successfully on the world stage for the first time, I found myself fascinated by something that had little to do with tactics, formations, or even goals. What captivated me was the emotion. Not simply the existence of emotion, but its intensity, visibility, and astonishing brevity. A player scores and immediately appears transported into a state of complete serenity. Fingers go into ears. Arms stretch outward. Eyes close. The face becomes almost beatific. A few seconds later, the moment is over. The player is jogging back to midfield. Another player misses a chance. Hands…
Read More

Before we reduce OAS Security

Blog
Comedian Aamer Rahman once discussed the idea of "reverse racism" in his 2014 standup comedy routine. His point was not that reverse racism was impossible, but before he could plausibly stand on a stage and ask, "What's with white people?", a remarkable number of historical reversals would first have to take place. White people would have needed to be excluded from jobs, housing, education, political power, wealth accumulation, and social influence for centuries. Only after all those reversals occurred would the question begin to make sense. The joke works because the audience understands that the necessary conditions simply did not exist. I find myself thinking about that routine whenever I read another proposal to lower the OAS clawback threshold in the name of intergenerational fairness. To do list before we…
Read More