Toronto’s culture of consultation: Six examples of process replacing outcomes

Blog
Toronto has developed a unique civic strength: it excels at conducting repeated consultations on strategies and visions. This process has delivered tangible results in areas such as the Eglinton Crosstown and improved snow removal. However,  Toronto’s track record on long-term social strategies and structural reform remains uncertain. We provide six examples below where processes replaced outcomes. But before we enumerate them, it is important to acknowledge the accomplishments and milestones that the City has achieved.  Toronto's accomplishments This year’s Toronto City Budget makes targeted investments in the services that matter most to communities across our city. It includes over $30 million in new and enhanced funding for key programs. There are also important increases to the Rent Bank to help prevent evictions and strengthened support for RentSafeTO to improve housing conditions. Student…
Read More

Champagne wishes and caviar dreams? The placid fiction of the Financial Facelift

Blog
Every Saturday, readers of The Globe and Mail are invited into a curious genre of Canadian journalism: the Financial Facelift. The formula is reassuringly familiar. A couple—usually in their late 50s or early 60s—appears with an impressive financial résumé. They have a paid-off house, substantial retirement savings, perhaps a cottage, and children who are either launched or nearly so. Their mortgage is gone, their careers have peaked, and their financial anxieties revolve around questions like whether to convert an RRSP early or delay withdrawals to preserve Old Age Security. Enter the expert panel or expert planner. Within a few paragraphs, the couple’s financial future is gently massaged into shape. The planners recommend some tax-efficient withdrawals, perhaps a bit of income smoothing, and the careful timing of CPP and OAS. Travel…
Read More

Why do we continue to isolate people living in poverty?

Blog
From workhouses to welfare rules to the silent architecture of separation  “You’ve ruined the community,” Ford reportedly told the facility’s staff. “You can’t destroy a community like this. People have worked 30 years for their home…My heart goes out to kids with autism. But no one told me they’d be leaving the house. If it comes down to it, I’ll buy the house myself and resell it.” “It’s turned into a nightmare for this community,” Ford said. “It’s been turned upside down.” - Doug Ford 2014 The backlash was immediate. But the impulse was ancient. Help them — somewhere else. Margaret Hillyard Little documented the overt version in No Car, No Radio, No Liquor Permit. Welfare recipients were inspected. Radios restricted. Cars forbidden. Relief came with humiliation. Assistance came with…
Read More

‘Just pennies a day’ –  the seductive lottery logic inside TV insurance advertising

Blog
Turn on daytime television in Canada and a familiar vignette appears. A person pauses during an ordinary activity—watering plants, sitting at the kitchen table, watching grandchildren play. They decide to make a responsible phone call. On the other end is a calm, reassuring voice. Almost anyone can qualify, the caller is told. No medical exam. Just a few lifestyle questions. The caller smiles. Relief spreads across their face. Soon the conversation turns to the possible payout—up to $250,000, perhaps more, available quickly if death is unexpected. The caller imagines what the money might do: cover funeral costs, help the family, pay for retirement planning, clear debts, leave something behind. Then comes the price: As little as a few dollars a month. The caller’s surprise is almost theatrical. That’s ‘less than…
Read More

Breaking the emergency department binary: Why Canada needs a continuum of care — and a more responsible narrative

Blog
“Thank you for calling the office of Dr. [Name]. Our office hours are Monday to Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. If you are calling to book or change an appointment, please remain on the line or press 1 to speak with reception. If this is a medical emergency, please hang up and dial 911 or go immediately to your nearest emergency department.” How often have you heard this? It cuts to the chase of an important binary. Canada has slowly built a healthcare system that forces patients into a false choice. If something might be serious — a flu that will not break, a strange growth, chest discomfort that may or may not be alarming — Canadians face two options: wait for a family doctor appointment that may…
Read More

Life course thresholds: Why do we wait for the fall?

Blog
Four quiet caregiving action thresholds   We are very good at recognizing crisis. We recognize the stairway fall.We recognize the stove fire.We recognize the utilities cut off.We recognize the unpaid tax bill with penalties attached.We recognize the emergency room visit. But caregiving rarely begins with crisis. It begins with smaller thresholds — inflection points — that are easy to dismiss because each one, taken alone, resembles ordinary human error. The question is not whether someone makes a mistake. The question is whether they can correct it. That distinction marks the beginning of something deeper. Building on earlier life-course thresholds — when stairs become unsafe, when grip weakens, when exercise becomes impossible — there are four earlier inflection points that often precede visible decline. They are subtle. They are cumulative. And…
Read More

Boomers, wealth, and the architecture of advantage

Blog
Why the generational debate misses the real design question A recent Pew Research analysis in the United States found that Baby Boomers hold more wealth at comparable ages than previous older generations did. At the median, American Boomers in 2022 were substantially wealthier than the Silent Generation in 2001 or the Greatest Generation in 1983. The predictable reaction followed: Boomers won. Younger generations lost. In Canada, the pattern is similar — but the interpretation is often incomplete. Yes, Canadian Boomers hold roughly half of total household wealth. Yes, average Boomer net worth exceeds $1 million. Yes, housing equity plays a dominant role. But the generational framing — Boomers versus Millennials — obscures something more important. This is not primarily a story about age. It is a story about architecture. The…
Read More

The ‘envelope test’ and CRA’s income tax double standard

Blog
I have written about CRA's enforcement and entitlement double standard before but always as part of a laundry list of complaints. This time I want to showcase it on its own. Imagine a restaurant server, honest and methodical, who one day finds an envelope at home marked “2024” with $1,200 in cash inside. He is at first surprised, then remembers it. It is not marked, not documented, and not connected to any slip on any tax form — it is just there. Being a law-abiding citizen, he does the only thing the system teaches him to do: he reports it to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) and offers to pay tax on it. On its face, that seems like an act of civic integrity. But what his experience exposes is…
Read More

The Olympics and the cult of maximum volume

Blog
A modest proposal for turning down the sound or changing channels I used to live across from a man whose sole civic function appeared to be shouting at children. Whenever we were playing road hockey, building snow forts, or engaging in any activity detectable by human ears, he would emerge and declare: “Hey, you kids! Shut up!” At the time, we viewed him as the villain in a small suburban opera. Now, watching the modern Olympics, I find myself sympathizing with him. Not because children are loud. Because everything is. Curling has discovered heavy metal Let us begin with curling. A sport whose essential mechanics involve granite stones gliding across ice at contemplative speed has somehow transformed into an auditory siege. The shouting is constant. Not directional calls. Not strategy.…
Read More

Cutting Old Age Security is not a test of courage

Blog
In a recent column, Robyn Urback suggested that if Mark Carney were truly serious about the economy, he might consider making “politically unpopular decisions … like reining in Old Age Security.” It was a throwaway line. But it reveals something deeper about how we talk — and don’t talk — about seniors’ income policy in Canada. OAS is clawed back through the tax system First, the premise is wrong. Reining in Old Age Security (OAS) is not some taboo that no government dares touch. We already do it. Since 1989, Canada has applied a 15% recovery tax on OAS for higher-income seniors. Above a defined income threshold (about $93,000), OAS is clawed back automatically through the tax system. It is not universal in any meaningful sense at the top. It…
Read More